TCHERS' VOICE / New Teachers

One Size Does Not Fit All: Why Moving Grade Levels Can Be a Great Thing

Tchers' Voice Teacher Retention Blog Header

As educators, we often come into the field with the perfect grade level in mind. I thought it would be ideal to teach second grade. Not too young, where students are still gaining independence and learning basic skills. Not too old, where they're bigger than me (an ongoing short joke for myself, as I'm only 5’3”).

When I actually began to teach second grade, I quickly realized that this was going to be tougher than I expected. My second grade students were great. I enjoyed my interactions with them. I enjoyed planning engaging lessons around stories such as Stone Soup, and teaching how to tell time. My students were independent enough to complete tasks given to them, but still wanted input and help with their work.

The Challenges

But what I didn’t anticipate were the many challenges coming my way. I'd heard all of the first year teacher horror stories, but I felt like this was different.

[video_embed src="https://www.teachingchannel.org/videos/differentiating-instruction/embed.js" width="480”]

  • Differentiation. I faced wide ability ranges. I had students who were working on sight word recognition and students who were reading at a sixth grade level. I had students who were working on basic addition and students who were multiplying three digit numbers.
  • PaperworkDifferentiating for all of these ability levels required different practice sheets, depending on the student. I was fortunate to work with an amazing team with whom I planned, and who helped a ton. But all of this paperwork had to be assessed, as well.
  • Assessment. I was completely oblivious to how much a second grader is tested throughout a school year. Once these tests are scored, the data is used as a driving point for the next semester.

As a new teacher, it was overwhelming.

Orange Dot Border

I spent the year giving it my best efforts, with the support of my team and a new teacher mentor, but I never really felt completely adequate.

[video_embed src="https://www.teachingchannel.org/videos/mentoring-for-new-teachers/embed.js" width="480”]

It was time to pursue other options because, as it turned out, second grade wasn't the perfect fit for me, for my family, for my sanity -- not if I wanted to remain in the teaching profession. So I made the tough choice to start over by moving to preschool.

My decision wasn't an easy one. Preschool was new and scary. Little ones. Have you ever seen Toy Story 3 with the classroom of students throwing and breaking the toys?

I was terrified! But it was there in preschool where I found my home. I knew from the first day, when those three and four year olds entered my classroom and we began to sing, dance, play, and read stories on the carpet, that I'd found my place.

Orange Dot Border

If you're on the verge of leaving the profession because you're feeling overwhelmed, stressed out, or inadequate, I encourage you to take a leap of faith. Change is hard and when you already have so much on your plate, moving grade levels or switching content areas may seem daunting, but I'd encourage you to give it a try before throwing in the towel. One size does not fit all and you may just find your niche in a new environment.

I've spent the last five years teaching in the preschool program and I'm thankful every day that I took the chance and tried something new.

Orange Dot Border

You Are Enough

Our profession and our students need good teachers like you.

Here are a few tips to support you if moving grade levels seems like the right choice:

  • Scope out your potential grade levels. Speak with teachers who are currently teaching in the grade or content area you're considering. Ask to observe their classroom and see what their day looks like. Note the pros and cons that you see.
  • Keep an eye out for openings. Are there any teachers leaving or new classrooms opening for the grade level or content area you're considering? Letting your administrator know that you're interested in these positions can give you an advantage if or when a position does open up.
  • Remain flexible and keep an open mind. Each grade level comes with its own set of perks and challenges. Give yourself time to get settled in and to learn the ropes. Pull from the knowledge of any colleagues or teammates who've been there before you and can help make your transition smooth.

Have you considered moving grade levels or have you already made the leap? What advice would you give to a teacher wrestling with a similar decision? Share your ideas in the comments below.

Orange Dot Border

Audra Damron is currently in her eighth year of teaching and her sixth year as a preschool teacher at Desert Oasis Elementary School in Phoenix, Arizona. She is a newly certified National Board Teacher. Audra graduated from Bowling Green State University in Ohio in 2010. 

4 Comments
This is really interesting, Audra, and the same holds true for high school, too. As a department chair, I make sure that each of the 23 teachers in my department teaches at least two different grade levels each year. It just helps with perspective. Thanks for sharing this.
Recommended (0)
All good points! Sometimes too veteran teachers (like me) just need new opportunities and challenges. Even feeling that a grade level is a perfect fit, after a number of years a change can rejuvenate your teaching.
Recommended (0)
Great blog. I completely agree. Even changing settings can bring renewal. Two years ago, I switched school districts. I felt unsupported by my administration and fearful that I would get in "trouble" for my teacher leadership actions. I moved to a school closer to home with a principal who encourages and supports me in my teacher leadership efforts. The change was big for me. For those who do change settings, be easy on yourself. I had a difficult first year getting acclimated to new school and district procedures. But the change was worth it. Here are my thoughts for those who change positions next year! http://www.storiesfromschoolaz.org/letter-dear-experienced-teacher-new-situation/
Recommended (0)
look at this https://www.teachingchannel.org/blog/2018/05/24/one-size-does-not-fit-all/
Recommended (0)

Tchers' Voice

Tchers’ Voice is filled with great ideas from passionate educators just like you. Let's get better together!