Question Detail

What are the advantages and disadvantages of the different types of assessment?

Sep 27, 2014 2:59pm

We've been discussing testing and assessing in my SPED grad class.

  • Other
  • Special Education


  • You must sign in before we can post your answer.
    Don't have an account? Sign up only takes a few seconds.

    • Sep 29, 2014 10:46am


      Any assessment that informs instruction is super valuable. Sometimes these assessments are called diagnostic assessments and other times they are called formative assessments, but the purpose is the same. When these assessments are given, teachers use the data/results to inform instruction, as they become aware of students' strengths and areas of weakness. I don't recommend using the results of formative assessments in a student's grade, as in theory, the material has not yet been taught and therefore a student should be not penalized for underperforming.

      After the formative assessment, teachers plan standards-based instruction to allow all students to access the curriculum - the rich data from the formatives allow teachers to set a scope and sequence for curriculum and instruction. Often during this time, informal assessments are given to check in to see where students are at, to determine if certain concepts need to be explored in more depth and also to determine if students are engaged in the process of learning. I find it valuable to ask students to access teacher instruction informally, as they can offer valuable feedback about their own learning.

      Once students have learned materials, through access to a universally designed curriculum, teachers can give summative assessments, which measure a student's growth since the formative assessment. If students have not yet learned the materials, Tier II intervention may be necessary to insure that all students have the opportunity to learn important background information before moving on to more complex topics.

      On a final note, none of these assessments have to be "traditional" in any way. Some teachers may choose multiple choice objective tests, that are more standardized, but both formative and summative assessment can take many different shapes. As long as the product allows teachers to assess student learning in response to specific standards, the assessment is doing its job.

      Katie Novak