Scaffolding Text Structure for ELLs Transcript
Speaker 1: In order to have students organize their writing in a clear, concise way, I have students use a claim, evidence, reason, structure.
So, our question, "Did world leaders make positive or negative choices during the Syrian Civil War?"
In the past student were writing but they weren't necessarily elaborating to the point where they were really explaining what they wanted to say.
Alright, why did you pick this one? Why is this one the strongest for you?
So, when we noticed that, we introduced the structure of starting with a claim, moving on to some evidence, and then explaining why in your reasoning, and those all correspond to a different color. So our claims are blue, our evidence is red, and our reasons are green and students know that because we have an anchor chart in the room that they can reference frequently.
The coloring just helps them to remember if they've already done one blue, one red and one green, they need to go back and do another claim, evidence, reason. So it helps them to sort of, build that structure over and over again, especially when they're writing a paragraph.
Speaker 2: So, first Bashar Al-Assad chose to attack the Syrian people.
Speaker 1: For all of these we use different sentence starters. For example, their claim should always start with a sequence word.
Speaker 2: So for example, according to my text-
Speaker 1: For evidence we use according to the text or based on the text.
Speaker 2: This show that-
Speaker 1: And for our reasons we always use, this shows blank because blank.
Speaker 3: This show that Russia had the government-
Speaker 1: So what I want to see from students is that their claim is pretty short, it's just a quick introduction of their idea. Red should be about double the size of their claim and then their reason should hopefully be very long. We want to see a really, a lot of green on that paper when they're writing.
So [Urn 00:01:41] do you want to respond to Louise's point?
Urn: Yeah, I disagree with her because according to the text it say-
Speaker 1: When they present their arguments during the debate, they'll read those and then they'll place them on one side of the room or the other. They'll place it on the yes side, or the positive side, or they'll place it on the no answer or the negative side. It helps them to see evidence accumulate for one side or the other.
I love that you're focusing on the idea that these are his own people that he's been attacking, right? Alright awesome.
So building it into that weekly practice has helped it just become a natural part of our class.i'd also say building a debate structure in this way, I would suggest practicing on a topic that's more familiar to the students and then moving up to sort of grade level content or more rigorous content.